Don't Just Take Web Content. Ask For Permission
June 11, 2009
So I finally jumped on the blogging bandwagon and started my own little blog-posting space, which can be
found here: http://water-roots.blogspot.com
At first I was very reluctant to activate the site because I’m a blog-commitment-phobe and the very
thought of having to keep up with such a thing in addition to my Water Roots website, caused me anxiety.
But I learned that there’s nothing to worry about.
For one thing, I discovered that you can schedule your posts for a later date (who knew?), which is
cool. Furthermore, you can schedule as many posts as you want for a later date, which is even cooler.
So that’s what I do. I write up a whole bunch of things whenever I have some free time and just
schedule them as I see fit. So there’s no need to commit time to the blog daily and rack my brain
trying to think of something to add. That type of pressure is just too much for a blog-commitment-phobe.
So the pressure’s off.
And since I was feeling pretty good about it all, and a little adventurous to boot, I decided to go one
step further (why not go all out?) and join Blotanical,
a wonderful online community of garden-themed bloggers from all over the world that I’ve visited
occasionally but been reluctant to join. Because of, you know, the commitment-phobia thing, which I now
realize applies to anything that requires some type of ‘time’ commitment.
Anyhow, so far it’s also proven to be relatively painless. I’ve received some nice welcome messages
from other members that I’ve replied to, and the traffic to my blog has increased. In addition, I’ve
discovered new blogs that are really cool.
Well, one blog led to another and suddenly I find myself on one that has some information
about hydroculture. Needless to say that I was very excited when I discovered this because it’s
difficult to find websites or blogs with information on this alternative growing style. I immediately
felt a kind of kinship with this woman whose site included information on an indoor gardening method
that I’m very passionate about.
Until I discovered that she was using some of my photos on her website without my permission. And
without referencing where she took them from. Took? Let’s call a spade a spade. Stole.
Can you believe this? I mean, the nerve.
You know, I’m a pretty friendly (and reasonable) individual and I certainly wouldn’t hesitate to give
my permission to someone who wanted to use one of my photos on their non-commercial website. But I
expect to be asked. It’s really not cool to just take (steal) someone’s photos, or anything else
for that matter, without their consent and add them to your site as if they’re your own. Especially
when the website that you have stolen photos from has a copyright page that specifically states in
very simple to understand language:
“... It is strictly prohibited to use any part of this website without
authorization… Written consent from the publisher must be obtained before the user can copy, publish
or reproduce any part of this website or the information on it.”
What part of the above statement is someone not able to understand?
Yes, I’m annoyed. This type of act demonstrates a complete lack of respect for someone else’s private
web space and its contents, as if these types of ‘individuals’ that go around ‘taking’ whatever they
please are somehow entitled to other people’s content on their website. Like photos. Or text. Or
whatever they damn well feel they’re entitled to.
Well, I hate to break it to the entitlement bunch, but permission needs to be granted if you want to
use whatever is on my – or anyone else’s - website. And it’s really not that difficult to attain in
my case. All you need to do is send me an email and ask me if you can use something. I’ve
learned to read, so rest assured that I’ll understand what you’re writing. Chances are you’ll even
get a prompt response. By me. Because in addition to reading, I’ve also learned to write. Cool, huh?
Even more than that, I will most likely grant you permission to use my photo or some part of my
content with the simple request that you reference my website. After all, it is my web content.
Not yours.
Is that too difficult to understand?
Is expecting this smidgen of courtesy too much to ask?
Is respecting copyright rules too hard to do?
And for crying out loud, there are websites out there that provide you with free images. You don’t
need to steal photos from someone else’s site. You can get some for free. No questions asked. No
permission needed. Odds are you’ll find one that suits whatever topic you’re writing about.
Here are a couple of links to help you shed
the ‘taking-something-that-doesn’t-belong-to-you-without-asking’ disorder:
http://www.morguefile.com/
http://www.sxc.hu/
Anyhow.
I believe that there are really only two things to explain why this woman used my photos without my
consent:
1) She really has no clue that this type of action is not acceptable and is innocent because of
ignorance. In addition, she did not see my copyright page.
Or
2) She knows that this type of action is not acceptable but doesn’t care. In addition, she did see my
copyright page but dismissed its message. After all, she’s entitled to her entitlements. She
doesn’t need anyone’s permission.
I’d like to believe that number 1 explains how this all came to be. That is the reason why I have not
included the name or link to this woman’s website. And because I’ve decided to give her the benefit
of the doubt in hopes that it’s all a misunderstanding, I informed her of my discovery and requested
that she a) remove my photos from her site because they don’t belong to her and she didn’t ask for my
permission to use them or b) reference Water Roots if she wants
to continue to use them.
I’m waiting to see what happens. An apology would be nice but I’m not holding my breath.
Instead.
If she removes my photos from her website because she doesn’t want to reference me, or if she wants to
continue to display my photos on her website and references me as I’ve asked, we’ll move along and put
this incident behind us. I’ll keep her site’s name confidential for all eternity and no one will be
the wiser.
But.
If she blows me off, I will publish the name and location of her website on this website and on my
blog. Because it’s not cool.
Sigh.
Everything else aside, it’s just good manners to ask. Most gardeners (indoors and out) are more than
willing to give their consent for usage of their photos or text on someone else’s site, which is in
fact very flattering. But you still have to ask. And you still need to credit the
author/creator/publisher/artist/writer. Capiche?
End of rant.
We now return you to the plant-related Hydro Logs...
Ahem.
Sorry to have wasted whatever little precious time I have to spare these days for Hydro Logs on a
rant. I promise to put up an article relating to plants as soon as possible. There’s a bromeliad
profile on the horizon...
Return to the Hydro Log main page